Progress Doesn’t Mean Completion: The Persistent Myth of Racial Equality

For centuries, the fight for racial equality in the United States has been marked by hard-won victories, from the abolition of slavery to the triumphs of the Civil Rights Movement. These milestones have undoubtedly transformed the lives of millions, dismantling many overt forms of racial oppression. However, they have also contributed to a dangerous and persistent myth: the belief that progress equals completion.

This myth, bolstered by landmark achievements such as the Civil Rights Act of 1964, the Voting Rights Act of 1965, and the election of Barack Obama in 2008, promotes the false narrative that racial inequality is a relic of the past. In reality, systemic inequities continue to permeate wealth, education, and criminal justice systems. These inequities expose the limitations of progress and highlight the enduring need for frameworks like Critical Race Theory (CRT) and the concept of caste to fully address these challenges. Notably, this myth of racial progress is not confined to any one group—Black, white, Hispanic, and others all grapple with its implications and flaws.

The Misconception of Historical Milestones

Historical milestones, such as the Civil Rights Act and Voting Rights Act, are often heralded as definitive endpoints in the pursuit of racial justice. While monumental, these achievements primarily addressed specific legal barriers rather than dismantling entrenched systems of racial inequality. For example, the Civil Rights Act outlawed segregation and discrimination in public spaces but did not address the economic and social structures rooted in centuries of slavery and systemic oppression. Similarly, the Voting Rights Act prohibited overtly discriminatory practices like literacy tests and poll taxes, yet voter suppression persists today in subtler forms, such as gerrymandering and restrictive voter ID laws.

These legal victories were necessary, but they were never sufficient to dismantle the broader systems of inequality. They served as stepping stones, not endpoints, in a much larger and ongoing struggle.

The election of Barack Obama further reinforced the myth of a "post-racial" America. Many Americans, across racial and ethnic lines, pointed to his presidency as proof that systemic racism had been eradicated—as if the election of a single Black leader could undo generations of structural inequity. However, voting patterns during Obama's campaigns reveal a more complex reality: he did not secure the majority of the white vote in either election. According to exit polls, only 43% of white voters supported Obama in 2008, and this number dropped to 39% in 2012. These figures highlight the persistent racial attitudes that shape American politics and serve as a sobering reminder that deep-seated divides remain unresolved.

While Obama’s presidency was symbolically powerful, it did not dismantle the systems perpetuating racial inequality. Instead, it became a convenient symbol for those eager to deny the ongoing existence of systemic racism. By celebrating the milestone of his election, many overlooked enduring disparities in wealth, education, and healthcare, prematurely declaring the fight for racial equality complete.

Enduring Disparities in Wealth, Education, and Criminal Justice

Although milestones like the Civil Rights Act marked progress, disparities in wealth, education, and criminal justice reveal that the fight for equality is far from over. These systemic inequities affect not only Black Americans but also Hispanic, Indigenous, and other marginalized groups, highlighting the need for broad societal change.

Wealth Disparities
The racial wealth gap remains one of the starkest indicators of systemic inequality. According to a 2019 Federal Reserve report, the median wealth of white families is nearly eight times that of Black families and five times that of Hispanic families. Discriminatory policies such as redlining, exclusion from the GI Bill, and unequal access to quality employment have compounded this disparity over generations. For example, families of color were historically denied access to affordable mortgages and higher-paying jobs, leaving them unable to accumulate wealth at the same rate as white families. The absence of generational wealth perpetuates poverty cycles and constrains economic mobility, undermining broader economic stability.

Educational Inequities
In education, disparities in funding perpetuate cycles of inequality. Schools serving predominantly Black, Hispanic, and low-income communities receive significantly less funding than those serving predominantly white students, according to a 2019 EdBuild report. This underfunding limits access to critical resources such as advanced placement courses, experienced teachers, and modern facilities, creating barriers to academic success. Even when students of color overcome these obstacles to pursue higher education, they face additional systemic barriers, such as disproportionate student loan debt. This financial burden further restricts their ability to build wealth and secure long-term stability, compounding the challenges of systemic inequity.

Criminal Justice Inequities
The criminal justice system exemplifies systemic racism. Black Americans are incarcerated at five times the rate of white Americans, while Hispanic Americans also face disproportionate rates of arrest and detention. These disparities are the result of policies like over-policing in marginalized communities, mandatory minimum sentencing, and racial profiling—not individual behavior. The consequences of mass incarceration destabilize families, restrict economic opportunities, and perpetuate poverty in communities of color. These systemic injustices demand a reevaluation of policies that prioritize punishment over rehabilitation or community investment.

The Psychological Comfort of Believing in Progress

The belief that racial equality has already been achieved provides psychological comfort to many Americans across racial and ethnic lines. This myth allows individuals to avoid confronting the uncomfortable realities of systemic racism and the difficult work required to address it. For some white Americans, this narrative offers a way to absolve themselves of responsibility, framing racism as a problem of the past. Meanwhile, individuals from marginalized communities may embrace this narrative out of frustration with the ongoing struggle or as a way to maintain hope.

This complacency is reinforced by the American ethos of individualism and meritocracy. Many believe success is solely a result of hard work, ignoring structural barriers that disproportionately impact marginalized communities. For instance, the idea of "pulling oneself up by the bootstraps" denies the systemic obstacles that make this impossible for many. This belief not only denies the existence of systemic racism but also perpetuates harmful stereotypes, further entrenching inequality.

The Role of Caste and Critical Race Theory

To dismantle the myth of racial progress, it is crucial to engage with frameworks like Critical Race Theory (CRT) and the concept of caste. CRT emphasizes that racism is not merely a matter of individual prejudice but a structural issue embedded in laws, policies, and institutions. By examining how racism shapes every aspect of society, CRT provides a lens for understanding persistent disparities.

Similarly, Isabel Wilkerson’s concept of caste, as explored in Caste: The Origins of Our Discontents, offers a broader framework for understanding systemic inequality. Wilkerson argues that race functions as a caste system in the United States, with rigid hierarchies dictating access to resources and opportunities. Both CRT and caste theory challenge the comforting but false notion that progress equals completion and provide the tools necessary to address the root causes of inequality.

A Call to Unity and Shared Responsibility

The persistent myth of racial equality is not just a problem for Black Americans—it is a national issue requiring collective action. Addressing systemic racism benefits all Americans by fostering economic growth, social stability, and trust in democratic institutions. This effort must go beyond acknowledging disparities and include tangible actions, such as supporting community organizations, advocating for equitable policies, and fostering inclusive dialogues.

Conclusion

The myth of racial equality, fueled by perceptions of progress, obscures the enduring realities of systemic racism in the United States. Milestones like the Civil Rights Act and the election of Barack Obama, while significant, do not signal the end of the struggle for racial justice. Disparities in wealth, education, and criminal justice reveal the unfinished nature of this fight and the need for continued action.

Frameworks like CRT and the concept of caste provide powerful tools for understanding and addressing these challenges. By acknowledging the complexities of systemic racism and fostering unity across racial and ethnic lines, Americans can confront the uncomfortable truths about inequality and work toward genuine equity. Progress does not mean completion. Only by continuing the fight can we fulfill the promise of racial equality for all.

2/2